________________ CM . . . . Volume VII Number 2 . . . . September 22, 2000

Horses of Suffield.

Nick Bakyta (Director). Katherine Rankin & Jerry Krepakevich (Producers).
Montreal, PQ: National Film Board of Canada, 1998.
46 min., 39 sec., VHS, $39.95.
Order Number: C9198 027.

Subject Headings:
Wild horses-Alberta-Suffield Region.
Suffield Region (Alta.)-Environmental conditions.

Grades 7 and up / Ages 12 and up.

Review by Ruth McMahon.

** /4

In 1994 (although the video does not mention the date of this episode), the feral horses that made their home at Canadian Forces Base Suffield were rounded up and adopted by citizens from across Canada. This video tells the story of the delicate mixed grassland prairie that was the home to 1,200 feral horses and the difficult, emotional story of removing these horses.
    The video explores the concerns of the World Wildlife Federation, Alberta Wilderness Association, and National Wildlife Service. The effects the horses had on the fragile grassland prairie were devastating. Water holes were being trampled and spoiled with horse dung. Several areas, including the middle sand hills, home to over 50 species of birds, were being over-grazed, and the erosion was changing the landscape. The habitat for 173 species of wildlife, 31 of which are rare, endangered or threatened, was disappearing. In 1992, a portion of CFB Suffield was established as a National Wildlife Area, a sanctuary for wildlife, and the public was forbidden entrance.
    In an attempt to represent all sides of the issue, ranchers, plus Doug Johnson, the man who broke more than 300 of the Suffield horses, were interviewed. In addition to a representative of the SPCA, a spokesperson for a coalition of various animal rights groups and a family that adopted a Suffield horse also had their say. The video is very careful to point out that the Suffield horses were feral (domesticated horses that returned to the wild), not wild horses. Although horses were native to North America, they disappeared 8,000 years ago for unknown reasons and were reintroduced in the 1500's by the Spanish Conquistadors. Background on the lifestyle of the feral horse, horse-breaking techniques, and the history of the horse are briefly addressed.
    A twelve-member citizens advisory committee, made up of defenders of both points of view, was struck to determine the fate of the horses. The committee's recommendation was to remove the horses. The military organized an adoption campaign and set aside the $90,000 profit for future environmental studies on the base.
    The other uses made of the land under the control of CFB Suffield are briefly touched on, as is the fact that every year 1000 acres of prairie are lost to agriculture. But the bulk of the blame for the disappearing mixed grass prairie is placed squarely on the shoulders of the feral horses.
    The footage of the horses and the prairie is outstanding. This video received several awards at the Missoula - International Wildlife Film Festival, including Merit Award for Editing, Merit Award for Conservation Message, and Best of Category - Second Place. The video clearly comes down on the side of the eco-system. The fact that the year of this controversy is never mentioned is a huge weakness and that the buffalo are never mentioned as part of the history of this region is another.
    For an interesting look at the mixed-grass land prairie, this is a good choice. For an unbiased look at the removal of the feral horses, it is less than perfect. The notes on the video jacket are minimal.

Recommended with reservations.

Ruth McMahon of Lethbridge, AB, lives 250 kilometers from CFB Suffield. An avid wildlife and birdwatcher, Ruth has little experience with horses.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.

Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364