________________ CM . . . . Volume XII Number 19 . . . . May 26, 2006

cover

Find It! Canada. A Search and Find Activity Book.

Jeff Sinclair.
Toronto, ON: Scholastic Canada, 2006.
32 pp., paper, $6.99.
ISBN 0-439-95778-8.

Subject Headings:
Canada-Miscellanea-Juvenile literature.
Picture puzzles-Juvenile literature.

Grades 3-6 / Ages 8-11.

Review by Dave Jenkinson.

*** /4

excerpt:

Mall Madness

West Edmonton Mall has it all! From rockin' roller coasters to awesome aquatic adventures. It's the Greatest Indoor Show on Earth. You'll need a keen eye to spot all the attractions. Have fun!

1. a tourist's camera

2. s-s-s-snow

3. a periscope

4. a scary shark

5. a fish out of water

6. a performing sea lion

7. the Alberta flag

8. 5 palm trees

9. a red golf ball

10. a purse

11. a butterfly

12. 2 chubby cacti

13. 6 stray balloons

14. a hockey stick

15. a treasure chest

16. a pair of sunglasses

17. Sharky the mascot

18. a high diving penguin

19. a sea turtle

20. a pink seashell

 

Find It! Canada's subtitle, A Search and Find Activity Book aptly describes the book's purpose. Consisting of 14 double page spreads of settings which are to represent nine of Canada's 10 provinces and two of its territories, the book calls for its “readers” to find 20 different items in each spread, with the list of these items being placed in a box superimposed on the illustration. The only other text accompanying each spread (and also contained in a box) is a brief description of the illustration's geographic setting (See excerpt.). As well, Sinclair adds an additional “bonus” challenge (and it truly is a challenge) in each spread by adding one Canadian item that does not belong in that particular setting and the reader has to identify what it is. Consequently, a little Bonhomme from Quebec's Winter Carnival can be found in the BC scene, the Wonderful West Coast,” while a seal is basking on a Manitoba beach in “At the Lake.” The words for these various things are then to be transferred to the book's last page where selected letters from the words will be used in solving a word puzzle.

internal art

     Though each spread lists 20 different things which are to be found, the actual number of items is higher than just 20 as each list requires its readers to find more than just one example of some things. In the above excerpt, the total number of items to be found in the West Edmonton Mall illustration is actually 30. The sole spread which actually contains just 20 total items is “Canada Day in the Capital” and the next lowest are “Winter Carnival” with 26 and “Mall Madness” with 20. The remaining 11 settings call for 40 plus items to be found, with “Stampede!” requiring a high of 65. Sinclair does provide a key to the bonus challenge, but there is not one for the item search. Consequently, if you can't find something, too bad. Keep searching. (I'm still looking for the tenth prairie chicken egg in “Flat Out Fun!” aka Saskatchewan .)

     Although Find It! Canada is principally supposed to be a fun activity book, its contents do transmit some bits of knowledge about this country. Oddly, however, Sinclair elected to exclude New Brunswick and the Northwest Territories while giving Ontario three spreads and Alberta two. “Canada Day in the Capital” is likely the least successful of the book's search and find spreads. While Sinclair used it to educate the book's readers about 20 Canadian inventions, some of the “inventions” did not lend themselves to illustration, and he was forced to label them, eg. Pablum, ginger ale, java script and Trivial Pursuit. If you didn't know what an Avro Arrow jet was, you could likely figure it out as there is only one plane in the illustration, but, if you had no idea of what insulin is, then your eyes could easily pass over the syringe and bottle. As a Manitoban, I was somewhat surprised that Sinclair selected Grand Beach to represent my home province. While Grand Beach has been identified as one of the world's best 10 beaches, Sinclair's scene bears little resemblance to the actual place. An artist must be allowed some creative license, but the waves on Lake Winnipeg never get high enough to support surfing!

     Gauging the audience level for the book is somewhat difficult as some of the spreads contain items well within a younger audience's knowledge base while others are much more challenging. Of the simpler variety is “Glories of the Fall,” an illustration of a Georgian Bay setting in autumn, which only requires children to locate common things, principally from nature, such as dragonflies, chickadees and a chipmunk. Prairie dwellers could have difficulty in identifying a turbot, mussels and schools of herring from Newfoundland's “Go With The Flow,” but then children living in the Atlantic provinces may not recognize words like silo, canola oil and turnip beetle which belong to Saskatchewan's “Flat Out Fun!”

     Sinclair's bright cartoon-like illustrations are certainly eye-catching, and while the book may have limited practical value in school or public libraries, Find It! Canada would be an excellent book to take along on those family vacations which call for children to be kept busy during long car rides.


Recommended.

Dave Jenkinson teaches courses in children's and adolescent literature in the Faculty of Education, the University of Manitoba.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.
 

NEXT REVIEW |TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR THIS ISSUE - May 26, 2006.

AUTHORS | TITLES | MEDIA REVIEWS | PROFILES | BACK ISSUES | SEARCH | CMARCHIVE | HOME