________________ CM . . . . Volume XXI Number 14 . . . . December 5, 2014

cover

Sink and Destroy: The Battle of the Atlantic. (I Am Canada).

Edward Kay.
Toronto, ON: Scholastic Canada, 2014.
202 pp., hardcover & EBK, $14.99 (hc.).
ISBN 978-1-4431-0781-5 (hc.), ISBN 978-1-4431-2884-1 (EBK).

Subject Heading:
World War, 1939-1945-Campaigns-Atlantic Ocean-Juvenile fiction.

Grades 6-8 / Ages 11-14.

Review by Mary Thomas.

*** /4

excerpt:

"Incoming torpedoes!" shouted the ASDIC operator. "Sounds like a freight train! They're coming straight at us from the stern, off to port side!"

Without a moment's hesitation the captain called out, "Hard to starboard!"

The bow swung round and the ship leaned over at a crazy angle. I hung on to my 4-inch gun to keep from getting thrown overboard. From my position I could see two trails of bubbles racing toward us from out of the dark, frigid water. Beyond that, there was just the blackness of a North Atlantic night.

After months of preparing and waiting, I finally had my first encounter with a U-boat. And now, as I watched the torpedo trails homing in on us and felt the ship turning agonizingly slowly as the helmsman threw the wheel around, I wondered if it would be my last.

 

 

Billy O'Connell was raised in the small Ontario town of Iroquois on the banks of the St Lawrence River at a time when the Depression was a presence in the home almost like a third parent. Not surprising then that, as the tide of joblessness began to recede with the threat of war, he quit school and went to work on a lakeboat ferrying grain from Port Arthur and Fort William down to the port of Montreal. After war was declared, it was a short step from lakeboat to corvette. He lied about his age and enlisted in the Canadian Navy.

     Sink and Destroy gives a picture of life in the very stable, but hideously uncomfortable, corvettes as they did escort duty across the North Atlantic, guarding freighters carrying grain and other essential supplies across to beleaguered Britain. And back again, riding high and empty. Both ways they were harassed by German U-boats, especially in the "Black Pit" -- the mid-Atlantic air gap or 600-mile stretch of water where they were out of range for air cover from either side.

     Danger on the high seas was countered by good times ashore, and Bill was amazed at how friendly and welcoming the Scots were, and by contrast, just how much sailors were mistrusted, resented, and exploited in Halifax. Billy doesn't seem to have had any idea why this should be, but it was not surprising that it was while he was stationed in Greenock that he acquired a girl friend, the thoughts of whom sustained him during times at sea. Their story should have ended happily ever after, but this was wartime, and it didn't. Aileen's house was bombed, and the whole family who had made Bill so welcome were killed.

     As the historical note at the back of the book says, "When the war began, Canada's Navy, like its Army and Air Force, was small, understaffed and ill-equipped for a major conflict." Young Bill has some exceedingly caustic comments about Prime Minister Mackenzie King: "the cheap bastard, living in his dream world, betting against all odds that the war wouldn't come -- and that if it did it could be fought with hand-me-down equipment from the First World War." This, after failing to sink a U-boat that could have been destroyed if he'd had a proper gun. At least by this time in the war, Billís ship did have guns! The first corvette that Bill sailed across the Atlantic in came equipped with a grey-painted telegraph pole mounted on its prow! Why? "No more guns," he was told.

     Sink and Destroy gives a graphic picture of the uncomfortable, dangerous life on board these corvettes, of the difficulties encountered on shore, and a lot of thoughts about the war, itself, as it ground on to its far-from-inevitable conclusion. What it does not give is a real feeling of immediacy and excitement. So, while I learned a lot, and was certainly glad that Bill survived, I had no great sense of involvement in his story. Sink and Destroy will be enjoyed by those "into" war and armies, but for readers who want an adventure that keeps them flipping the pages, the book will be rewarding but a bit disappointing.

Recommended.

Mary Thomas lives in Winnipeg and works in elementary schools there. Her engineer father spent the war in Ottawa, turning sewing-machine factories into gun producers, and this book indicates why he was more use there than in the trenches.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission.
Published by
The Manitoba Library Association
ISSN 1201-9364
Hosted by the University of Manitoba.
 

CM Home | Next Review | Table of Contents for This Issue - December 5, 2014 | Back Issues | Search | CM Archive | Profiles Archive