________________ CM . . . . Volume XXIV Number 37 . . . . May 25, 2018


When Paul Met Artie: The Story of Simon & Garfunkel.

G. Neri. Illustrated by David Litchfield.
Somerville, MA: Candlewick Press (Distributed in Canada by Random House Canada), 2018.
48 pp., hardcover, $23.99.
ISBN 978-0-7636-8176-4.

Grades 6-10 / Ages 11-15.

Review by Ellen Heaney.

*** /4


Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel were huge folk/pop music icons of the 1960s and '70s. They make for a rather unusual choice for this picture book biography.

      Each page in When Paul Met Artie is headed with the title of one of the songs that they made famous, and the text is set out in columns like a poem. However, it is not poetry but a melodic prose account of their backgrounds, how they met and how they collaborated in the success that was to become theirs. (The quotations in this review are reproduced showing the line breaks used in the book.)

          In this world of sameness,
          two boys born
          three weeks apart
          grow up a few blocks
          from each other
in a neighborhood
          called Kew Gardens Hills.
          The two boys are
          opposites in every way.

      Simon is shown to be the bolder of the two, the class clown, but Artie charms with his pure singing voice, "a human jukebox". Both are drawn to the world of the new popular music, listening to the revolutionary sounds of rock and roll together on the radio. But as they sing along, they realize their voices are different from those of Elvis and Jerry Lee Lewis. When they discover how to harmonize and Paul brings his guitar into the mix, they begin to develop a signature style.

      Their first public performance is at a junior high school dance.

          Walking together
          into the middle of the crowd,
          they clear a space.
          They have no band,
just Paul's guitar
          and their voices.
          Paul counts off and
Artie's high, sweet voice
launches into a series
of outlandish sounds –
ding-dongs, allangs
and ba-doodle-ays.
Kids are craning their necks
to see what's going on
when Paul comes in with
his warm, soft voice, crooning
to a song called "Sh-Boom"…
They set the song free
with their unique sound.

      They go on to bring together an informal doo-wop group, then appear on American Bandstand singing an original composition and calling themselves Tom and Jerry. But the end of high school seems to bring an end to their dream of being a duo, and they go their own ways to pursue academics and a few attempts at solo performing.

      It is the sound of musicians like Bob Dylan and the anti-establishment spirit of the 1960s that brings them together again in the orbit of the New York music scene. They score a contract with Columbia Records on the strength of their demo, The Sound of Silence. The ensuing album, however, is a flop.

      Again they separate, travelling and attempting to find themselves as individuals. When college radio stations in Gainesville, Florida and Boston start to play The Sound of Silence at request of listeners, excitement builds. And Simon and Garfunkel end up at the top of mainstream radio play in January, 1966.

          At the dawn of a new year
          the new kings of the charts
          have no idea that their lives
          will be forever changed.
          For one last moment,
          sitting in the car together
          Paul and Artie
          are still just
          two boys
          from Queens
          dreaming about
          the future.

      Back matter to the book includes a summary of the careers of Simon and Garfunkel following their first number-one recording; a discography; and a bibliography. The final three pages are headed "Musical Connections" which gives a detailed chronicle of the music and musicians who influenced the pair.

      Digitally-produced illustrations in colour with sepia overtones give the appearance of rich watercolours. Pictures range from intimate vignettes, such as the two boys' heads on an old cabinet television in a dimly-lit living room, to streetscapes and concert crowds. The artist has a number of picture books (Miss Muffet, or What Came After; The Marvelous Moon Map) to his credit.

      The story of friendship and musical achievement is intimately told, and the reader is invited to truly understand the early arc of this artistic partnership. Author G. (for Greg) Neri, known for his graphic novels and young adult fiction, lives in Vancouver, BC.

      Despite its format, When Paul Met Artie is not a book for primary collections. It would probably be most useful when offered to middle school or junior high students interested in 20th century popular music. Because of the book's limited audience, When Paul Met Artie is…

Recommended with Reservations.

Ellen Heaney, a retired children's librarian, lives in Coquitlam, BC.

To comment on this title or this review, contact cm@umanitoba.ca.

© CM Association

Hosted by:
University of Manitoba ISSN 1201-9364

This Creative Commons license allows you to download the review and share it with others as long as you credit the CM Association. You cannot change the review in any way or use it commercially.

Commercial use is available through a contract with the CM Association. This Creative Commons license allows publishers whose works are being reviewed to download and share said CM reviews provided you credit the CM Association.

Next Review | Table of Contents for This Issue - May 25, 2018.

CM Home | Back Issues | Search | CM Archive | Profiles Archive