________________ CM . . . . Volume XXIV Number 38. . . . June 1, 2018


The Spoon Asylum.

Caroline Misner.
Saskatoon, SK: Thistledown Press, 2018.
266 pp., trade pbk., HTML & PDF, $15.95 (pbk.).
ISBN 978-1-77187-155-6 (pbk.), ISBN 978-1-77187-160-0 (HTML), ISBN 978-1-77187-161-7 (PDF).

Grades 9-12 / Ages 14-17.

Review by Ann Ketcheson.

**** /4



He handed Haven his harmonica and pressed it into his palm.

“Here,” he said. “You take the mouth organ and learn to play it. I’ll teach you.”

“That would be swell. But I don’t think I could ever learn to play it as good as you.” The harmonica was warm, the engraving faded to obscurity by Jude’s hand.

“You keep staring at me while I play that thing night after night with your mouth hanging open like you’re trying to catch flies,” Jude replied. “You might as well learn to play so you don’t have to watch me no more. Besides, I got my spoons now, and my cigar box is ready for strings. That’s all I need.”

Haven turned the harmonica over in his hand. It was well worn from play. He raised it to his lips and blew softly through the comb. A faint whoosh was all the sound that came out.

“Other side,” Jude laughed.

Haven turned it around and tried again. This time a shrill note burst through his fingers just as elation burst from his heart. I can play this. Easy. If I can play the cornet, I can play this. “That’s it.” Jude nodded. “That there is a middle C. You know where that is, you can learn to play anything you want.”

Within the hour, Haven learned to play a chopsy rendition of “Home on the Range” while Jude tapped a hambone across his thigh. He nodded at Haven in time to his spoons, grinning his encouragement each time Haven hit the right note. When they finished, they collapsed against their chairs, startling the moths that collected along the edge of the screen, guided there by the light from the kitchen window.

Haven slept with the harmonica tucked in his shirt pocket that night. Wetherby was already snoring fiercely in his bed across the room and Jude muttered in his sleep, his head periodically lolling from side to side on the pillow beside Haven. He patted the instrument and smiled, grateful to have found jazz and Jude and Wetherby. He didn’t know how he had managed to live the past seventeen years of his life without them.


When Haven Cattrell is abandoned by his father in the small northern Ontario town of Davisville, he can’t imagine what the future holds. He knows he won’t be happy living with his grandmother, but he also recognizes that he has no money and so doesn’t seem to have many options. In the Depression of the 1930’s, work is hard to find. Luckily, he is able to find a summer job at a nearby Camp Nokomis, a summer camp for girls.

     Caroline Misner presents an interesting protagonist in Haven. As a city kid, he must learn the ropes very quickly once he starts work at the camp. He must adapt to new ways of doing things and new people, and, as the ‘new kid’, he is naturally the target of some practical jokes. As the novel progresses, Haven learns a great deal, not only in the practical sense of how to set a table and do some basic cooking but in the sense of learning about himself on a deeper level. He is introduced to jazz music and finds something in it that speaks to him unlike anything he has ever experienced. As well, Haven discovers more about his family background and also meets his first love.

     Other characters in The Spoon Asylum are as interesting as Haven. At the camp, he meets Wetherby and his son Jude, both black jazz musicians who have been out of work thanks to the effects of the Great Depression of the 1930’s. Another musician who has arrived in the area after riding the rails as a vagrant is Marcus who is employed at the boys’ camp across the lake. All three musicians play major roles in fostering Haven’s love of music and his growing talent.

     Among the female characters there is the indomitable Miss Nokomis, the owner and director of the camp. In many ways, she is not just what she appears to be, and this becomes more interesting and evident as the story progresses. Among the campers, readers meet Mabel and Charlotte. Both girls intrigue Haven and help him discover what it means to love someone and develop a meaningful relationship with her.

     Misner creates an entire world in the book, helping her young adult readers understand the realities of the Great Depression, an era of working hard, making do and having little or nothing to show for one’s efforts. As well, the author brings her readers into the world of early jazz music and musicians. On the darker side, readers realize that racism and anti-Semitism were part of life, even in a small, seemingly sheltered, community.

     As well, Misner gives her readers a sense of northern Ontario with her setting of a summer camp on a lake. The campers swim and canoe and enjoy the many activities associated with camp holidays. Although the small town is not far away, the girls usually only visit to attend church on Sundays. Otherwise, their life is one of lake and forest and the solitude of nature.

     The title of the novel is open to interpretation. Certainly the camp is an asylum for both the staff and the girls. It provides a place of refuge, safety and sanctuary on a variety of levels for the characters. But there are hints of the ‘insane asylum’ meaning of the word as well. The spoon of the title may refer to the utensils of the kitchen where both Jude and Haven work or to the musical instrument which seems to give so much joy to Jude when he plays.

     The Spoon Asylum will appeal to many different readers. Adventure and romance, pathos and humour are sprinkled throughout the story. Musicians will enjoy reading about the instruments played by various characters as well as the references to some of the great composers, singers and songs of the jazz age. Students interested in history will be immersed in the Depression years of the 1930’s as well as seeing the results of the racism and anti-Semitism at that time.

     Caroline Misner has written a novel which has wide appeal, interesting and memorable characters, an insightful understanding of the 1930’s Depression era, and a meaningful coming-of-age theme for young adults.

Highly Recommended.

Ann Ketcheson, a retired teacher-librarian and teacher of high school English and French, lives in Ottawa, ON.

To comment on this title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.

© CM Association

Hosted by the University of Manitoba.
ISSN 1201-9364
This Creative Commons license allows you to download the review and share it with others as long as you credit the CM Association. You cannot change the review in any way or use it commercially.

Commercial use is available through a contract with the CM Association. This Creative Commons license allows publishers whose works are being reviewed to download and share said CM reviews provided you credit the CM Association.

Next Review | Table of Contents for This Issue - June 1, 2018.

CM Home
| Back Issues | Search | CM Archive | Profiles Archive