I am stating my own opinion.

• identified my point of view clearly?
• remained relevant to the question?
• remembered to state my major point in my introduction?

I am responding to someone else's opinion.

Have I:

• indicated whether I agree or not?
• identified the strengths as well as weaknesses of the other point of view?
• been fair-minded in evaluating all points of view?

I have drawn some conclusions or made interpretations of some information.

Have I:

• based them on some kind of evidence?
• checked to see if they are consistent with each other?
• based them on assumptions? If so, what are they?

I am using evidence to support my claims.

Have I:

• restricted my claims to those supported by the data I have?
• checked that all information used is clear, accurate, and relevant to the question at issue?
• used sufficient information?
• considered information that opposes my position as well as information that supports it?

I have based my claims on some assumptions.

Have I:

• clearly identified my assumptions and determined whether they are justifiable?
• considered how my assumptions are shaping my point of view?

I have used some concepts and ideas that others may not understand or may interpret differently.

Have I:

• identified key concepts and explained them clearly?
• considered alternative concepts or alternative definitions to concepts?
• made sure I am using concepts with care and precision?

I have come to a definite final conclusion about the issue.

Have I:

• traced the implications and consequences that follow from my reasoning?
• searched for negative as well as positive implications?
• considered all possible consequences?